ViewGuide

Created Jan 31, 2009 05:24AM PST • Edited Jan 31, 2009 05:24AM PST

1. Quality

2. Summary

   Perfect 5.0

   After seeing Milk, a much-needed biopic of perhaps the most important politician of the last half of the 20th century, I have a renewed respect for Sean Penn. He is among the contemporary powerhouse testosterone-heads like De Niro, Pacino, Hoffman, Hopper, Nicholson, you know, swarthy New Yorkers who use heavy method acting despite today’s cynicism towards it. He was at one time the prototypical Hollywood punk who punched extras and photographers, did drugs and chain-smoked. Here he faithfully and lovingly reflects one of the most honest, understanding and loyal people in history, to an extent that none of his said peers have shown the balls to.

   Van Sant’s masterpiece begins with Milk remembering into his tape recorder about an individual passage that sparked at the ripe age of 40! At that cut-off point, he grew discontented with his life, determined he wanted to really accomplish something. A Republican stock researcher, he mingled with hippies in Greenwich and tiptoed the closet door, waving out hesitantly. He was in love with Scott Smith, played so becomingly by the underused James Franco. This is all absorbed from one scene, shot in a single, mostly stationary take. They moved to San Francisco, opened a camera shop and saw that even America’s leading, most strident gay community was being methodically victimized by police.

4. Acting

   Really Great 4.5

   Sean Pean Definatly Should Win Best Actor.

5. Male Stars Perfect 5.0

6. Female Stars Great 4.0

   It’s about a gay guy so there really isn’t a lot.

7. Female Costars Really Great 4.5

8. Male Costars Perfect 5.0

   THe names are very well known, and they are great actors.

10. Film

    Perfect 5.0

    Beautifully crafted, enveloping massive amounts of time, people and spirit without a frame of half-heartedness or drained momentum, this tenderly handled picture tells the story of its hero’s ascent from disgruntled middle-aged hippie to nationwide icon. Entwined are his romances. He remained dormantly in love with Scott after they separated due to his political concentration. He is instinctively caring even of a second lover who becomes irrationally resentful of his political life, when the practical thing would be to sever the bond.

    His most critical rapport was with Dan White, an apparently straight fellow supervisor, a Catholic who said homosexuality was a sin and canvassed with his family in red, white and blue. A thorny pact formed between Milk and White. If I were to criticize the film at all, I would lament that the depiction of the camaraderie between Milk and Mayor George Moscone is given far too little screen time.

    I see this film as not only a product of incredible dramatic and visual talent but also a righteous breakthrough of humanity in a most trying time for it. We never hear about the countless important gay men and women in history, but now Gus Van Sant, himself gay, has at last given us an accessible mainstream movie about one of them. To prove a significance for themselves today, when their basic rights are still being challenged, they, and we, have to relate to one of them in the past, as this film makes clear.

11. Direction Perfect 5.0

12. Play Perfect 5.0

13. Music Really Great 4.5

14. Visuals Really Great 4.5
15. Content

16. Edge

    Sordid 2.9

17. Sex Titillating 2.1

    Homosexual sex talk.

18. Violence Savage 4.2

    The scene at the end is very violent and disturbing.

19. Rudeness Salty 2.3

    Gay insults and stuff like that.

21. Reality

    Natural 1.0

    Based off a true story.

22. Circumstantial Natural 1.0

23. Biological Natural 1.0

24. Physical Natural 1.0