John A Massie's Review
Created Oct 13, 2007 08:19PM PST • Edited Oct 13, 2007 08:19PM PST
-
Quality
-
Perfect 5.0
One of the finest Westerns ever made, The Proposition is a bloody, haunting, beautiful, violent epic poem and the savagry of man, the harshness of nature and the country of Australia.
-
Perfect 5.0
The whole cast is amazing. Standouts include John Hurt, Danny Huston, Guy Pierce and the unbelievably great performance by Ray Winstone.
-
Male Stars Perfect 5.0
-
Female Stars Perfect 5.0
-
Female Costars Perfect 5.0
-
Male Costars Perfect 5.0
-
Perfect 5.0
The film looks amazing, the music and dialouge have a haunting lyrical quality.
-
Direction Perfect 5.0
-
Play Perfect 5.0
-
Music Perfect 5.0
-
Visuals Perfect 5.0
-
Content
-
Obscene 5.0
Very, Very violent in places. Not for the faint of heart.
-
Sex Explicit 5.0
-
Violence Monstrous 5.0
-
Rudeness Vile 5.0
-
Natural 1.0
-
Circumstantial Natural 1.0
-
Biological Natural 1.0
-
Physical Natural 1.0
|
Oct 14, 2007 2:03AM
Wick
|
I have to say I’m very interested in seeing The Proposition now that I’ve read Massie’s review. Westerns are one of my favorite genres, and the notion of a Western from Down Under is intriguing on its face. I sort of recall The Proposition when it came out, but it passed without a trace. Now I’ll have to rent it. |
- John A Massie
- 13 Trust Points
- 87 Reviews
-
RSS feed
Really Great |
Its pretty difficult to write a lot about Jackass movies ... |
|
Very Good |
I think my main problem with this film is that because I'... |
|
Great |
Not as entertaining as the first film and the plot had a ... |
|
OK |
The start feels rushed and a lot of the middle feels loos... |